Here’s yet another willfully obtuse Liar Distorts reader (and a self-described “logician,” at that). I’ve put up a brief reply over at my own blog, which summarizes some key points already made but scattered over several posts from the last few days – and which, if these people have a shred of intellectual honesty or decency, will end this stupid discussion once and for all. Which means, of course, that it probably won’t end.
UPDATE: For what it’s worth, over in the comments section at my own blog, my pro-choice colleague Hugo Schwyzer – whose own pro-Tiller posts inspired my original Tiller/Dahmer post – rejects any suggestion that I approved of Tiller’s murder. (And no, I did not ask Hugo to do this – indeed, other than a quick greeting in the hallway we haven’t had a chance to talk since this controversy started.) As he always does in his disputes with his right-of-center opponents, Hugo exhibits what Leiter et al. never do: a sense of honor and fair play.